Introduction

Unraveling the Cause of Relapsing Neurological Symptoms in a 51-Year-Old Female

History of Present Illness

Welcome. Your patient today is Jane T.

Jane, a 51-year-old female, initially presented to her primary care physician eight months ago with complaints of severe fatigue, left-sided facial weakness, and bilateral sensorineural hearing loss. Despite her symptoms, she had no significant medical history and led a relatively active lifestyle, enjoying gardening and community volunteer work. Initial treatment with intravenous steroids for 5 days resulted in significant symptom improvement over several weeks.

However, one month later, she experienced a relapse with worsening neurological symptoms, including leg weakness, right-sided appendicular ataxia, and frequent falls. She also developed increasing difficulty speaking, a tingling sensation in her head and neck, and persistent headaches. These new neurological symptoms prompted a hospital visit, where she was again treated with intravenous steroids, leading to partial symptom resolution.

Over the next several months, Jane continued to experience relapsing episodes characterized by fluctuating neurological deficits, including recurrent visual disturbances, ataxia, and limb weakness. Each episode showed a pattern of initial steroid responsiveness followed by symptom recurrence.

Based on her clinical presentation and MRI findings, she was diagnosed with chronic lymphocytic inflammation with pontine perivascular enhancement responsive to steroids (CLIPPERS). She was treated with a short course of intravenous corticosteroids, followed by oral prednisone for maintenance therapy.

Approximately 1 month ago, Jane’s condition deteriorated when she began tapering the corticosteroids, prompting her to visit the hospital. She reported progressive leg weakness, right-sided appendicular ataxia, and frequent falls. Additionally, she experienced increasing difficulty speaking, a tingling sensation in her head and neck, and persistent headaches. These symptoms, despite ongoing immunosuppressive treatment and relapse upon taper, raised concerns about whether the CLIPPERS diagnosis fully explained her condition.

Routine hematology, biochemistry and metabolic panel results were within normal limits, ruling out systemic metabolic abnormalities as a contributing factor.

She presents to you for further evaluation in an attempt to clarify the diagnosis.

Family and Social History

No known family history of autoimmune or demyelinating diseases. She denies tobacco use, drinks alcohol socially, and has no history of recreational drug use. No known environmental exposures or infections in her recent history could explain her symptoms.

Review of Systems

General: severe fatigue.

Neurological: left-sided facial weakness, progressive leg weakness, right-sided incoordination, frequent falls, slurred speech, persistent headaches, and tingling in the head and neck.

Ophthalmologic: bilateral blurry vision.

Physical Examination Notes

Jane is alert but fatigued, with left-sided facial weakness, slurred speech, lower extremity weakness (3/5), and right-sided ataxia. Sensory deficits in the head and neck and brisk reflexes with bilateral Babinski signs are noted. Gait is severely unstable, limiting mobility.

Consultation

Ask the patient — choose a question to play the interview.

Full transcripts below

Transcript · Revisit the previous diagnosis

Doctor: Good morning, Jane. I understand your symptoms initially improved with steroids but have unfortunately worsened again. From what I understand, the symptoms returned while you were tapering off the steroids, is that right? How are you feeling today?

Jane: Not great, to be honest. I’m really frustrated. The steroids seemed to help at first, but once I started tapering, everything came back — and worse. I’m having more trouble walking and balancing, and the headaches just won’t go away.

Doctor: I can see how that would be incredibly frustrating. Let’s go over your history and the previous diagnosis. You were initially diagnosed with Chronic Lymphocytic Inflammation with Pontine Perivascular Enhancement Responsive to Steroids, also known as CLIPPERS based on your symptoms and MRI findings, correct?

Jane: Yes, that’s what I was told. The MRI showed something in my brainstem, and they said the steroids were the treatment. It made sense at the time because I felt better for a while.

Doctor: That’s true—CLIPPERS is an inflammatory condition, and the initial response to steroids fits that diagnosis. However, the relapse and relapsing symptoms despite treatment raise questions. CLIPPERS typically responds well to ongoing low-dose steroids or other immune therapies, but in your case, the symptoms have returned and progressed.

Jane: So, does that mean it’s not CLIPPERS?

Doctor: It’s possible. Many conditions can look similar on imaging or have overlapping symptoms. Your symptoms, particularly the combination of hearing loss, balance issues, and the pattern of your MRI findings, suggest we need to reconsider the diagnosis.

Jane: What else could it be?

Doctor: There are a few conditions we’re investigating. Some involve immune processes that attack specific parts of the nervous system, and others might mimic CLIPPERS but behave differently over time. CLIPPERS, in particular, tends to respond well to steroids long-term — but in your case, symptoms reappeared during the steroid taper, which is not typical for CLIPPERS. The next steps will involve more specific tests to pinpoint the underlying cause.

Jane: So, it might have been a misdiagnosis?

Doctor: That’s a possibility, and it’s not uncommon with conditions like this. Neurological disorders can be complex and evolve in ways that give us new clues over time. What’s important is that we’re reassessing and tailoring the plan to what your body is telling us now.

Transcript · Ask about Jane’s childhood

Doctor: Hello Jane, can we go over your history again?

Jane: Why? Is there a problem?

Doctor: Well, looking at your MRI again, the imaging isn’t typical for CLIPPERS. So I want to make sure we’re not missing anything. Can you recall anything unusual from your childhood?

Jane: Yes. When I was 7, my parents told me I had a really high fever, and for a while, I couldn’t speak properly. My mom said I was slurring my words, and I remember going blind.

Doctor: That sounds concerning. How long did those symptoms last?

Jane: A few weeks, maybe. My parents were really worried and took me to the hospital. The doctors gave me some kind of steroids and I eventually got better.

Doctor: Did they ever determine what caused it?

Jane: Not exactly. They thought it might have been optic neuritis, maybe triggered by a virus. But once I recovered, we didn’t really look into it further.

Doctor: And did anything similar happen as you got older—during adolescence or adulthood?

Jane: No, not really. I was fine until a few years ago when my hearing started to decline. It got worse over time, and I eventually needed hearing aids. But I never thought it had anything to do with what happened when I was a kid.

Doctor: We also checked your bloodwork, including both your hematology and metabolic panels, to rule out any underlying systemic issues. Everything came back normal, so there’s no concern about things like anemia, infection, or organ function affecting your symptoms.”

Jane: Okay, so nothing unusual there?”

Doctor: That’s right—your blood counts and metabolic markers are all within the expected range. Based on this, we need to revisit your diagnosis. Your history of fever, vision loss, hearing loss, and difficulty speaking—along with your recent symptoms—suggests we might be dealing with something more complex. We’ll need to run additional tests to get a clearer picture.

Jane: Alright, that’s fine. Thanks Doctor.

Tests

Select appropriate tests for the patient — order and sequence are part of the exercise.

Neuroimaging & CSF Analysis

Serum aquaporin-4 (AQP4) and myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) antibody testing

Diagnoses

Select the best diagnosis.

Your first answer is recorded before any feedback is shown — commit to the diagnosis you would act on.

NameAction
Select a diagnosis to continue

Existing Diagnoses

NameStart dateEnd date
Optic neuritis secondary to viral infection……
CLIPPERS (Chronic Lymphocytic Inflammation with Pontine Perivascular Enhancement Responsive to Steroids)……

Case Review

Jane, a 51-year-old female, initially presented to her primary care physician with complaints of severe fatigue, left-sided facial weakness, and bilateral blurry vision. Despite no significant medical history, she led a relatively active lifestyle, enjoying gardening and community volunteer work. Initial treatment with intravenous steroids for 5 days resulted in significant symptom improvement, and based on her clinical presentation and MRI findings, she was diagnosed with CLIPPERS and started on ongoing corticosteroid therapy for disease maintenance.

However, despite being on chronic steroid treatment, Jane experienced a relapse one month later, with progressive leg weakness, right-sided appendicular ataxia, and frequent falls. She also developed increasing difficulty speaking, a tingling sensation in her head and neck, and persistent headaches. These new symptoms prompted a hospital visit, where she received another course of intravenous steroids, leading to partial symptom resolution.

Over the following months, Jane continued to experience relapsing episodes, characterized by fluctuating neurological deficits, including recurrent visual disturbances, ataxia, and progressive limb weakness. Each episode followed a pattern of initial response to steroids, followed by symptom recurrence despite ongoing corticosteroid therapy. The persistence of these relapses raised concerns that the initial CLIPPERS diagnosis did not fully explain her condition, prompting further evaluation.

Subsequent investigations, including repeated neuroimaging, cerebrospinal fluid analysis, and serum antibody testing, ultimately led to the diagnosis of MOGAD. Her relapsing course, MRI findings, and positive MOG-IgG antibody confirmed the diagnosis, highlighting the importance of reassessing patients with ongoing disease activity despite treatment.

Key Diagnostic Clues from Her History and Presentation

  • Childhood neurological event: her history of a multifocal neurological episode, characterized by fever, dysarthria, bilateral vision loss, and unilateral weakness, followed by resolution with steroids, points to an inflammatory demyelinating process. This relapsing pattern is consistent with MOGAD and not typical of static conditions like CLIPPERS or granulomatous diseases like sarcoidosis.
  • Sensorineural hearing loss: the unexplained development of bilateral hearing loss highlights systemic neurological involvement, which can occur in MOGAD, because MOGAD can cause polyfocal demyelinating brain lesions that involve key structures related to auditory processing .
  • Current presentation: Jane’s current symptoms of bilateral blurry vision, facial weakness, progressive leg weakness, appendicular ataxia, dysarthria, and multiple falls. The lack of symptoms confined to the pons or cerebellum (typical of CLIPPERS) helped exclude this alternative diagnosis .
  • Imaging findings: her brain MRI revealed multifocal supra- and infratentorial demyelinating lesions, including brainstem involvement, without the characteristic symmetric perivascular pontine enhancement seen in CLIPPERS . The multifocal nature aligns more closely with MOGAD.
  • CSF and serum studies: CSF and serum studies in Jane’s case further support the diagnosis of MOGAD. The absence of oligoclonal bands and a high IgG index in the CSF ruled out multiple sclerosis (MS). Additionally, negative infectious and vasculitis panels excluded alternative inflammatory or infectious causes. Most critically, Jane's MOG-IgG titre of 1:100 was a clear positive, reinforcing the diagnosis. Jane's combination of brainstem involvement, characteristic MRI findings, lesion resolution over time, and negative AQP4-IgG testing strongly supports MOGAD as the correct diagnosis .
  • Relapses despite ongoing corticosteroid therapy: Jane’s relapsing course despite ongoing corticosteroid therapy further suggested that her initial diagnosis of CLIPPERS was incorrect. CLIPPERS is a chronic inflammatory condition that typically remains steroid-responsive with stable disease control on maintenance therapy. However, Jane’s recurrent relapses, with initial steroid responsiveness followed by symptom recurrence, were atypical for CLIPPERS and more consistent with a relapsing demyelinating disorder such as MOGAD. This pattern of steroid-dependent but relapsing disease progression was a critical clue prompting further evaluation, ultimately leading to the correct diagnosis.
You will be returned to the home page

MOGAD — Educational Patient Case 2 · Or.01.24 · Jane T.

Faculty — Tania A Reyna, MD, MSCS, FAAN

Supporter — UCB

IntroductionConsultationTestsDiagnosesCase Review